O Lord, Our Lord -- Horatio Richmond Palmer

Is music medicine? Would you call it salve, maybe therapy for a sufferer? In the case of Horatio Richmond Palmer, one might think music was a call from deep inside his consciousness, something subliminal.  Although his life was devoted to music, he’s credited with writing just a few songs, including composing the words and music for the hymn “O Lord, Our Lord” in 1874. Now, what was hidden about that song,  that might make you think he was concealing something? After all, he’s proclaiming to everyone through the song that there’s a great and magnificent Lord, the most important confession anyone can make. Look at Palmer a little closer, and see if you think there’s something else there.

Horatio Palmer began his musical life early on in New York state, a vocation and an obvious passion that we can assume lasted throughout his lifetime, given the number of musical ventures in which he was involved. Maybe his father, Anson B. Palmer, deserves the most credit for Horatio’s direction, for it was he who undoubtedly endorsed his son’s inclusion in the church choir (directed by the elder Palmer) at the age of just seven.  Horatio’s mother had died when he was just three years old, in 1837, leaving Horatio’s upbringing to his father, and perhaps not insignificantly to the church’s musicians too. For the next several decades, this son of the choir director studied, organized, and led numerous musical endeavors, including a chorus of many thousands at Madison Square Garden. What a sound that must have been! At the age of 40, Palmer wrote “O Lord, Our Lord”, a composition he must have envisioned a large chorus of angelic-like voices directing upward, if you’ve ever heard it. We know not the precise incident that inspired Palmer to write this hymn, but there are two things we can surmise, with a little exploration. Palmer chose words from David the Psalmist (Psalm 8) to echo his praise to Him, so Horatio had a palpable passion for his God that he wanted to convey in a grand way, worthy of Him. Looking at its construction, and comparing it to other songs that Palmer wrote, there is also an interesting pattern. Female voices alone begin the hymn, just a composer’s routine choice, or a habit? Two other earlier Palmer compositions (“Love One Another” [also known as “Angry Words”] in 1867, and “Yield Not to Temptation” in 1868) also exhibit this same tendency. Horatio obviously appreciated the female voice, and wanted to hear it without male accompaniment. Did he miss his mother’s influence in his early life, even into adulthood? Perhaps he did, even if his father and the church helped fill the gap. (Although a commenter [see it below] tells me that Palmer had a stepmother...thanks for the information!)

How did Palmer fare, despite his birth mother’s absence through most of his life? From all appearances, Horatio Palmer was a productive, God-fearing, positive influence. Maybe he never knew something was missing. Look at David, Horatio’s musical predecessor…who was his mother? We know his father was Jesse, at least here on earth. Perhaps the more significant parent for David was the one in heaven. It wouldn’t be too hard to deduce that Horatio Palmer had perhaps figured out that part too. I’m part of a family, and my goal is to be part of one forever. There’s only one place and one parent that can make that come true.  

http://www.cyberhymnal.org/bio/p/a/l/palmer_hr.htm