Just look at these pictures (shown here, in 1890 and 1915,
respectively) of this slum, and see if you think the poet-composer should have
reconsidered where he was about to go. Just the name of the place -- Hell’s
Kitchen -- might have given Ernest W. Blandy serious pause, yet he must have
really thought that “Where He Leads Me I Will Follow” to himself as he prepared
for this change. One of his contemporary
hymn writers (Fanny Crosby) had likewise made the same choice to live in a NYC
slum, so Ernest may have felt he should expect nothing less of himself. Did Mr.
Blandy have some affinity for the Irish immigrants that lived in this
poverty-stricken, crime-ridden area? We can only speculate, but we know that
Ernest didn’t try to outthink what he was doing. He just followed.
Little is known of Ernest W. Blandy, except that he
evidently had a strong faith and worked that out in a ministry in this
aforementioned slum. He was reportedly
an officer in the Salvation Army, so he must have been accustomed to spending a
lot of time with poor folks in rough circumstances. Given the choice of an
assignment at a decent church (unknown location) and Hell’s Kitchen, he chose
the latter in 1890. He apparently felt, according to the words of “Where He
Leads Me…”, that the Lord was directing him there. Had family, friends, or
other acquaintances asked him to explain this apparently radical choice, which
would expose him to probably daily hazards? After all, this rough neighborhood
had earned its name; a mission house was there, and though Ernest may have
indeed been familiar with it because of his role as a Salvation Army member, it
was also associated with a murder some 15 years later (see 2nd of
the two pictures above). Hell’s Kitchen was overcrowded and inhabited by crime
gangs, so lawbreaking was a way of life for many of its residents. Step on
others, or be stepped on yourself. Ernest’s musical response to these issues
was not terribly involved – just a few words were all he used. Ernest heard and
followed (v. 1), including through anticipated life-threatening circumstances
that were perhaps only somewhat less hair-raising than Jesus’ own footsteps through
the garden and into unfair judgment (vv. 2 and 3). One can fathom that Ernest’s
sense of duty compelled him to mimic Christ’s determination. Like Jesus when he
did the dirty job of washing feet (John 13), maybe Ernest considered his own
trial in Hell’s Kitchen would be acceptable because he knew he was headed for a
glorious home, eternally (v.4). He reasoned he could go ‘all the way’ (refrain)
while here on earth. We may not know much of Ernest Blandy, but his choice for
Hell’s Kitchen and the rationale he shares in “Where He Leads Me …” perhaps say
all we need to know.
Ernest was glued to Jesus Christ, we could say, except for
one bit of truth. Ernest had a choice. He could have gone to the established church
and been relaxed, safe. Perhaps Jesus was more like the strong magnet for
Ernest, with an attraction he just couldn’t ignore. Or, how about a persistent
sound? A wind chime at my neighbor’s house has a deep, resonant bong when the wind blows, and my ears
just cannot disregard the sound at night. Ears do not just shut off, with the
flip of a switch. (My solution is to drown it out with something louder.) Ernie
Blandy had ears, too, ones that could hear that divine bong. The Son has something you and I cannot discount. Is that what
He meant when he said he would draw others to Himself (John 12:32)?
See very brief information/biography on composer and all
four verses of the song, see the following site: http://www.hymntime.com/tch/htm/w/h/e/r/wherehlm.htm
See this site for general description of the area where the
composer was headed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell%27s_Kitchen,_Manhattan